Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
Next revision | Previous revision | ||
personal:blog:2017:0113_my_program_for_a_better_france [2017/01/13 09:33] antonello |
personal:blog:2017:0113_my_program_for_a_better_france [2018/06/18 15:11] (current) |
||
---|---|---|---|
Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
With my great surprice a candidate of the left primaires said yesterday that he favour a regionalisation of Pole d' | With my great surprice a candidate of the left primaires said yesterday that he favour a regionalisation of Pole d' | ||
That's my primary point! Pole Employ is a waste of resources and time. Nobody can seriously pretend it is useful. And my poiint is that the primary reson is that it is trying to put together two things that require a different model of governance. | That's my primary point! Pole Employ is a waste of resources and time. Nobody can seriously pretend it is useful. And my poiint is that the primary reson is that it is trying to put together two things that require a different model of governance. | ||
+ | |||
The first one is the management of the allocation chromages. To avoid people have their rights, not less but above all not more, managing a benefit require a certain rigidity of the system. But France has already organisations that are specialised in dealing with benefits, the Casse Allocation Familiaires. My point is that the allocation chromage should just be dealed by the CAF rather than Pole Employ. | The first one is the management of the allocation chromages. To avoid people have their rights, not less but above all not more, managing a benefit require a certain rigidity of the system. But France has already organisations that are specialised in dealing with benefits, the Casse Allocation Familiaires. My point is that the allocation chromage should just be dealed by the CAF rather than Pole Employ. | ||
+ | |||
The other function of Pole employ is so help the demand and the offer of jobs getting closer, including professional training. | The other function of Pole employ is so help the demand and the offer of jobs getting closer, including professional training. | ||
+ | |||
But job markets are mostly local, not national.. and also this " | But job markets are mostly local, not national.. and also this " | ||
=== More taxes within the general income taxation === | === More taxes within the general income taxation === | ||
- | Generally speaking, and France doesn' | + | Generally speaking, and France doesn' |
The problem with France is that the general income tax is something somehow " | The problem with France is that the general income tax is something somehow " | ||
- | My idea is instead to semplify | + | |
+ | My idea is instead to simplify | ||
Line 23: | Line 28: | ||
Here French people will hate me (so, any how, I would never win the election, even if I could candidate myself as President :-)). They are bombarded with what I believe is a romanticizing of the real situation: everywhere it is stated that the health system is one of the best in the world. No, it is not. It is just a middle, average one for developed countries (take as parameter for example the child mortality at one year). What is it true is that it is instead one of the most expensive one. The OCSE claim it to be the thirds most expensive after the American and Duch ones. | Here French people will hate me (so, any how, I would never win the election, even if I could candidate myself as President :-)). They are bombarded with what I believe is a romanticizing of the real situation: everywhere it is stated that the health system is one of the best in the world. No, it is not. It is just a middle, average one for developed countries (take as parameter for example the child mortality at one year). What is it true is that it is instead one of the most expensive one. The OCSE claim it to be the thirds most expensive after the American and Duch ones. | ||
+ | |||
The problem for me is that between the doctor and the patient there is a way to excessive " | The problem for me is that between the doctor and the patient there is a way to excessive " | ||
+ | |||
Mutuels are companies. They offer they services but they have to pay their staff. Big staff, and many shops. | Mutuels are companies. They offer they services but they have to pay their staff. Big staff, and many shops. | ||
+ | |||
I am confident that a system with a unique, national, universal, public health care is way more efficient. After all we are not choosing to be unwell! | I am confident that a system with a unique, national, universal, public health care is way more efficient. After all we are not choosing to be unwell! | ||
+ | |||
To be feasible, the public health care should be act like what people want from an insurance.. protect her from big, unpredictable risks. | To be feasible, the public health care should be act like what people want from an insurance.. protect her from big, unpredictable risks. | ||
- | So, for relatively affordable health expenses (that constitute the majority of the expenses) a quota of the costs should still be put charg to the patients, | + | |
+ | So, for relatively affordable health expenses (that constitute the majority of the expenses) a quota of the costs should still be put charge | ||
The idea is that people should be guarantee that while they may have to pay a bit of pocket money for they minor health problems, when things start to be serious or resources are not sufficient, the public health care is there. | The idea is that people should be guarantee that while they may have to pay a bit of pocket money for they minor health problems, when things start to be serious or resources are not sufficient, the public health care is there. | ||
- | ACTUALLY IT IS NOT MUCH DIFFERENT THAT WHAT EXIST NOW | + | |
- | But the problem is mainly a communication problem. All people I knew of, they have a mutuel because they don't know how the system works! The system is so complicated that even health professional doesn' | + | ACTUALLY IT IS NOT MUCH DIFFERENT THAT WHAT EXISTS |
+ | |||
+ | But the problem is mainly a communication problem. All people I knew of, they have a mutuel because they don't know how the system works! The system is so complicated that even health professional doesn' | ||
So, my point is mainly to simplify the rules so that everyone is reassured that when they have serious health problem, the State is there. | So, my point is mainly to simplify the rules so that everyone is reassured that when they have serious health problem, the State is there. | ||
Line 36: | Line 50: | ||
The problem of too big administrative layer is not unique to the Health system, but is virtually everywhere in the State' | The problem of too big administrative layer is not unique to the Health system, but is virtually everywhere in the State' | ||
+ | |||
The health system is very expensive, still doctors are paid very little. The education system is very expensive, still teachers are paid very little. | The health system is very expensive, still doctors are paid very little. The education system is very expensive, still teachers are paid very little. | ||
+ | |||
I could continue the list. | I could continue the list. | ||
- | France has one of the highest public workers share in developed countries. This would not be a problem if they are productive positions, but as I said most of these positions are " | + | |
+ | France has one of the highest public workers share in developed countries. This would not be a problem if they are productive positions, but as I said most of these positions are " | ||
No-one want to sack people and increase unemployment. Even just stopping to assume people in the public sector is a inter-generational ethical problem and private the public system of new, young energies (we saw the damages this policy has done in countries where it has been implemented, | No-one want to sack people and increase unemployment. Even just stopping to assume people in the public sector is a inter-generational ethical problem and private the public system of new, young energies (we saw the damages this policy has done in countries where it has been implemented, | ||
- | My idea instead is that we should encourage people, trough life-long learning and qualification policies, to move on to more productive functions while fulfilling their own ambitions. Going beyond the traditional full cycle of studies to get a profession, many people could achieve | + | |
+ | My idea instead is that we should encourage people, trough life-long learning and qualification policies, to move on to more productive functions while fulfilling their own ambitions. Going beyond the traditional full cycle of studies to get a profession, many people could achieve | ||
~~DISCUSSION~~ | ~~DISCUSSION~~ | ||